Resistance to Change October 1, 2024 Excerpted and adapted from a shiur by HaRav Nissan…
Q&A from the Bais HaVaad Halacha Hotline
Half Note
June 6, 2024
Q I observe the second half of sfirah. May I play music during the second half at the wedding of someone who keeps the first? If so, may I buy a new suit for the occasion?
A It is a matter of debate among contemporary poskim whether one who keeps the second half may participate in a wedding after Lag Ba’omer. The Minchas Yitzchak (4:84) says that he may not, but he may attend the chupah, because the main celebration is only later.
Many rely on R’ Moshe Feinstein (Igros Moshe 1:159), who rules leniently, explaining that the wedding prohibition is solely on the chassan and kallah, and because they are permitted to marry, guests may attend. They may also attend the sheva brachos, even with music.
If you are a professional musician and are being paid to play at this wedding, all agree that you may do so (Kovetz Halachos 9:9, based on the Pri Megadim, who allows playing music at a non-Jewish event during the Nine Days). If you need to practice before the wedding, you may do so.
Some have the custom of refraining from purchases like a suit while observing sfirah (see sources in Piskei Teshuvah 493:3). But others point out that there is no halachic basis for this. Those who avoid it do so to acknowledge the sadness of the period, but there is no obligation, even if a Shehecheyanu will be recited on the new suit (Kovetz Halachos 8:5).