skip to Main Content

Eisav selling the first born

Rav Daniel Dombrov

How could Eisav sell the rights of the first born to Yakov?

  1. Regarding the double portion of inheritance, it is considered a davar shelo ba l’olam.
  2. Regarding the leadership and other aspects, these are intangibles and considered a davar she’ayn bo mamesh.

Ketzos- this is determined based on an individual’s ability to renounce his rights of inheritance.

A husband may renounce his rights to inherit his wife because his ownership is only midrabannan.  Therefore, a bechor, which is de’raysa, can not renounce his rights of inheritance.

Ran- Ordinarily, one cannot renounce his rights to inheritance after he is in a position to inherit. [A husband may renounce his rights only prior to marriage.] Nevertheless, the first born is unique, in that it is not considered to be a standard inheritance, but rather, a Torah mandated ‘gift’. If so, Eisav was in a position to at least renounce his right to the first born.

Ohr HaChaim – davar shelo ba l’olam is lacking gemiras daas. When one is in a desperate situation, there is gemiras daas even on a davar shelo ba l’olam.  Eisav was acting out of desperation, which accords full gemiras daas to the kinyan.

Additionally, concerning selling an intangible item- davar she’ayn bo mamesh– when one accompanies the transaction with an oath- a shevuah- the transaction is binding.

Rosh- prior to Matan Torah, there was no issue transacting in a davar shelo ba l’olam. The Rivosh disagrees with this.

NEW Yorucha Program >