WHEN CHAMETZ MEANS BUSINESS

DOES THE STANDARD MECHIRAS CHAMETZ PROCEDURE SUFFICE FOR THE CHAMETZ OF A BUSINESS?

By Dayan
Shmuel Honigwachs, Shabbos and Kashrus Division, Bais HaVaad

In this article we will address the following scenarios:

• A business that sells chametz products via an online marketplace like
Amazon

• A business that must serve chametzon Pesach, such as a health-care facility

• A business that depends on chametz, e.g. a trucking company that hauls bread

• A business that sells chametz that may be returned either on or after
Pesach

• A business that sells chametz on consignment

• A business that profits indirectly from the sale of chametz on Pesach, e.g. a property owner who leases space to Dunkin’ Donuts

SELLING CHAMETZ
ITEMS ON AMAZON

Amazon’s popular FBA
(fulfilled by Amazon) program enables sellers to pre-position their goods in
Amazon’s warehouses to be picked, packed, and shipped when the seller receives
an order. When an item is sold, it may still be the seller’s property, but
because he cannot recall it, it is aino birshuso. May he sell it with
his regular mechiras chametz?

According to many poskim, including R’ Moshe Feinstein,[1] the owner of chametz that is aino birshuso does not violate bal yeira’eh, obviating the problem. The Chazon Ish,[2] though, disagrees. 

An additional basis for
leniency is that because the seller cannot recall the chametzafter the
order is placed, it may already be the property of the gentile purchaser.[3]

However, another possible
concern in this case is that the seller has achrayus for the chametz.
Although accepting achrayus for chametz of a gentile that is located on
the gentile’s property does not generally pose a problem, this may not apply to
chametz that had once been on the Jew’s property.[4]

A BUSINESS THAT
SERVES, SELLS, OR DEPENDS ON CHAMETZ ON PESACH

A business that utilizes chametz in any aspect of its operations (e.g., a trucking company, a landowner that leases space to Dunkin’ Donuts, or, according to some, a health-care facility that serves chametz) is deriving benefit from chametz, which is an issur hana’ah. Such cases are described in halacha as mistacker b’issur hana’ah, earning money from an issur hana’ah. These businesses are earning money from the chametz of others, making mechiras chametz both irrelevant and impossible.

A nursing home that
purchases chametz during Pesach may have an additional problem utilizing
the standard mechiras chametz in that more chametz will be
purchased after the mechirah. The issue of mistacker, though, may
not apply to a nursing home because it can, theoretically at least, operate
without servingchametz.

SELLING CHAMETZ THAT
CAN BE RETURNED

Suppose a Jew sells chametz
to a gentile shortly before Pesach with a 30-day return window, and the
purchaser returns the item during or after Pesach. The return nullifies the
sale retroactively, leaving the Jew in possession of the chametz during Pesach.
In this case, too, the customary sale performed by one’s rav may have no
effect, because the chametz wasn’t birshuso at the time of the mechirah.

Whether this situation is
considered aino birshuso is the subject of a dispute between the
Ketzos Hachoshen[5] and the
Chasam Sofer.6 Again, according to the view of the Igros Moshe, the
prohibition of bal yeira’eh wouldn’t apply if the chametz isn’t birshuso.

Reselling the returned chametz,
however, would present a problem of chametz she’avar alav haPesach.
Because the matter is contentious, a competent posek should be
consulted, or one may utilize the solution offered at the end of this article.

SELLING CHAMETZ ON
CONSIGNMENT THROUGH A GENTILE

In this case, halacha considers the chametz to
be birshuso and it can be sold with the standard mechiras chametz procedure.
This is because consignment is similar to an iska, which the Ketzos
Hachoshen[6] and
Nesivos Hamishpat deem to be birshuso.

THE SOLUTION

The ideal solution for all
of these issues is to sell the entire business, rather than just the chametz,
to a gentile. The proper kinyanim must be employed to effectuate the
sale, in addition to drafting and executing a legally-binding contract. Since
the contract is recognized by dina d’malchusa, it is considered kinyan
situmta (industry custom), which is effective even for items that are aino
birshuso. (There is a possibility that a secular court may not uphold this
contract, and therefore a kinyan sudar is additionally performed.) This
would also allow the owner to continue to operate the business during
Pesach—provided that a valid Shabbos/Yom Tov arrangement is in place—because the
payments he receives are the interest from the sale of the business rather than
a benefit from chametz.

If one does not sell the
business with a sales contract, it is still beneficial to list the business in
the standard mechirah document.

For more information regarding the sale of business chametz or to execute a specialized business chametz sale agreement, please call Dayan Shmuel Honigwachs at the Bais HaVaad office at 732.276.1309 or email info@thehalachacenter.org.

To sell your personal chametz online, go to www.baishavaad.org/chametz

[1] או”ח
ח”א קמ”ו

[2] ‘או”ח קי”ח ד

[3]  עי’ באג”מ דמיירי ששלח ישראל לישראל במתנה באופן שודאי חייב המקבל להחזירו אם לא חזר בו הנותן קודם שמשך המקבל משא”כ בניד”ד דכיון דע”פ דינא דמלכותא אין המוכר יכול לחזור פקע בעלותו

[4]  עי’ באג”מ (או”ח א’ קמ”ו) אלא דיש להסתפק אם היה כותב כן בניד”ד דשאני התם דמיירי שבעלות הישראל מעולם לא פקע וה”אחריות” דמדובר שם מיירי בדין הואיל דיכול לשאל עליו דזהו המשך מבעלותו הקדום וא”כ י”ל דדוקא התם לא מיקרי מקבל אחריות על חמצו של עכו”ם בבית עכו”ם כיון דהאחריות הוא המשך מבעלותו הקדום של הישראל משא”כ בניד”ד דמכר החמץ לגוי ואח”כ מקבל עליו אחריות בעלמא י”ל דהוי קבלת אחריות שמתחיל ברשותו של גוי ע”כ לא החלטתי לאיסורא ודו”ק

[5]  סי’ שנ”ד

[6]  סי’ ס”ו